-1 in Montreal, Quebec

Positive Pay in S4 HANA times (1709 and up)

Positive Pay in S4 HANA times (1709 and up)

  • Posted by: Adrian
  • Category: DMEE, DMEEX, FCHX, PosiPay, Positive Pay
I will start by explaining what Positive Pay is (for those who know, you can skip this part). It is a popular Service in North American banks that they provide to prevent fraud on printed checks that you issue. You issue / print a check to pay a Vendor and you mail it via regular Post mail. At the same time, usually by the end of the day, you will produce a file as per your bank specifications for this service with all the issued checks list with date, amount and beneficiary and send it to your bank. 
Once your issued check is presented to be paid by your Vendor at the bank, they cross ref it against the info you have provided them. If any of the data does not match, they will stop the payment of that check and send you an exception notice (online). Then you will decide if the check gets paid or not. This way you can prevent check fraud by someone that could have altered any information in the check (usually amount and/or beneficiary) to get away with it. If you do not have that service, your bank could easily end up paying your check, leaving you on the hook to absorb the fraud.
A few years ago, a client of mine, had a check altered. The mail somehow was intercepted, they copied all the info in the check into a brand new check and a $450 CAD check got converted into $23k CAD check. The bank end up paying it. Luckily, for my client, we also had Electronic Bank Statement (EBS) in place and the next day the check was paid. We were trying to reconcile it, the system could not find that check number with that amount. Then we started investigating in our system and found out that check number was for $450 instead of $23k. They call right away the Bank and thanks God the bank recognized it and absorbed the hit. In this case, Positive Pay would have been ideal to directly stop it from being paid.

How we used to do Positive Pay in SAP before S/4 HANA 1709 ?

Standard SAP Tcode FCHX (Program RFCHKE00) is designed to output a file that provides this exact information (to a certain point) so you can send it to your bank. But …. There is always a but. Each and every bank has its own set of requirements when it comes to Positive Pay and the file specifications vary from Bank to bank, they are not standard like EBS or electronic payments. So this program will not work out of the box for you. If it does, you should buy a lottery ticket !
This program works with 2 internal Structures DTACHKH (Header) and DTACHKP (Line items / checks) where all the “necessary” information is output. I put necessary between quotes, because in some cases your bank might ask you for some extra info.
There were a couple of alternatives to solve this until today:
#1 – Take a copy of this program and make a Z Transaction (this is the more popular one and I have done it a couple of times already). You will also copy these 2 structures and make them Z. Then once you have a copied program, you can control the info you need, the file format, the logic, etc. That way you will output a file as per your bank specifications. If you were to need this for several banks, you will do as many Z programs as banks you have. Or you can enhance if further to have some sort of bank selection so you control different output file formats all in one program.
#2 – Modify the standard delivered structures (DTACHKH and DTACHKP) to include or remove what you need. This does not give you a lot of flexibility and you will be limited to only 1 bank. If in the future you have another bank, this approach will not work.
#3 – Do a full custom program to create your own extract and build your file as per your bank needs. At the end, all the information is somehow stored in Tables REGUP and REGUH. It is more work as you have to build a program from scratch, a selection screen, file handle, etc. In a sense is what FCHX already does. I have seen this approach being suggested by people in Internet. (Not the one I will go with).
#4 – Use FCHX the way it is out of the box, let it create the file. Then create a 2nd program that will grab this file and format it (and enhance if needed) the way you need it for your bank. (An old client of mine did it this way).
#5 – Do the same as option #4 but transform your file in your middleware directly and then send it to the bank directly from there.
As you can see there are many options with pros/cons and more or less effort.
My preferred option was always #1, up until I recently discovered a new SAP standard delivered way that comes with S/4 HANA 1709 (FPS02) which is the environment that I was working with.

How do we do Positive Pay in SAP S/4 HANA 1709 today ?

Way simpler, quicker and less custom (Z) than it used to be ….
Now Standard SAP Tcode FCHX (Program RFCHKE00) allows you to work with a DMEE structure so you can design and output your custom file as per your bank’s needs without the need for an Abap, program or structure modifications. You just design your output file with the Tcode DMEEX (Extended DMEE) and then you can output the file.
As you can see in the screen shoot below, FCHX has a line at the bottom where you can specify your “Payment Medium format”. This last line / option, was not there before in previous versions, like in ECC6.0. Now as of 1709 you have this possibility.
Then when it comes to build your output file, you work it with DMEEX (Extended, not the traditional DMEE. But it is almost the same) the same way as if you were building any other electronic payment file to your bank. But instead of this file being called by your Payment Program (F110), it will be called by FCHX.
Once you have fill out the corresponding info in your selection screen file, you will execute it and a file will be created. (see confirmation message below)
Now … Where is that file going ? It is being created in TemSe or Tcode FDTA (Fiori App “Manage Payment Media”).
Then you go there, enter your selection criteria and execute.
Once you are here, you select the line and download the file as you might already be doing with any other electronic payment file.
In this case I created a custom DMEE called “ZBOA_US_POSIPAY” as per my Bank specifications. In this case Bank of America.
With S/4 HANA 1709, there is a standard delivered DMEEX format for Positive Pay that you can use as an starting point to create your own custom DMEE. This DMEE is called “US_POSIPAY”. You will copy it and create your own Z Format. You can create as many custom DMEEs formats as banks you have. This way you do not need to change your FCHX program. You only need to change the “Payment Medium format” in the execution screen. This way you stay standard and there is no issues when it comes to an upgrade.
This saves you the need to do Abap, and you are completely independent as any Functional FICO consultant with the right knowledge can do it. It does not require development anymore.
Note: FCHX out of the box has an issue to work with any other DMEE other than standard delivered US_POSIPAY and requires you to implement an OSS Note to correct this bug. Probably I was one of the firsts in the world to have attempted to use this solution as it was not working and SAP did not know about it. I ended up reporting it to SAP via an OSS Message. It took me around 2 months of exchange with them before they finally ended up releasing this OSS Note. After that it works well. So now I am able to say that there is an OSS Note out there that was released thanks to me.
This Note applies to S4CORE 102 (1709), 103 (1809), 104 (1909).

OSS Note

If your Company and/or Project needs to implement this or any of the functionalities described in my Blog, do not hesitate to reach out to me and I will be happy to provide you my services.

Author: Adrian

Leave a Reply


  • Hi ,

    I'm looking to implement the positive pay using DMEE XML file not the flat file along with check printing.
    I have customized my own DMEE in XML format & I'm using CHECK format for printing the physical check however
    the cheque printing is taking place but positive pay file is not getting generated.

    & I'm not using the FCHX program to trigger the positive pay file.

    Kindly advise.

    Arun Gattani

  • Hi, If you do not execute FCHX, there is no other way to get this Positive Pay file created and there is no program executing / calling this after you print your checks; specially if you are using the Fiori App "Manage Automatic Payments".
    If you are still using the old F110 (which I hope you are not these days), you could have it to call the FCHX program with a Variant.